高级检索

    甲酸和乙酸对铅质文物腐蚀影响对比

    Comparison of Corrosive Effects of Formic Acid versus Acetic Acid on Lead-Based Artifacts

    • 摘要: 博物馆环境中有机挥发性甲酸(HCOOH)和乙酸(CH3COOH)气态污染物都会明显腐蚀铅质文物,但腐蚀过程和产物种类形态有所差别。模拟不同湿度的无酸、甲酸、乙酸环境,对铅试样进行腐蚀试验,根据其质量损失、光泽度、腐蚀形貌和产物物相等指标分析了铅在不同环境中的腐蚀过程和机理。结果表明:在不同湿度环境中,甲酸和乙酸对铅都有明显的腐蚀性,其中乙酸对铅的腐蚀尤为突出。甲酸和乙酸均能破坏铅表面的PbO钝化层形成甲酸铅、乙酸铅,乙酸铅易转化为疏松的碳酸盐并释放乙酸,形成循环腐蚀;甲酸铅则会在中低湿度(相对湿度≤75%)下形成对基体具有一定保护作用的致密晶体,但相对于无酸环境,其腐蚀性仍然明显。铅质文物保存展示中需严格避免使用释放甲酸、乙酸气态污染物的展陈材料。

       

      Abstract: Gaseous pollutants formic acid (HCOOH) and acetic acid (CH3COOH) are both significant causes of corrosion for lead-based artifacts in a museum setting. However, their corrosion processes and the types/morphology of the resulting corrosion products differ markedly. Corrosion tests were conducted on lead samples in simulated acid-free, formic acid, and acetic acid environments under varying humidity levels. The corrosion processes and mechanisms of lead in different environments were analyzed based on indicators such as mass change, glossiness, corrosion morphology and corrosion product phase. The results demonstrate that both formic acid and acetic acid exhibited significant corrosiveness towards lead across a range of humidity levels, with acetic acid causing particularly severe corrosion. Both acids attacked the PbO passivation layer on the lead surface, forming lead formate Pb(HCOO)2 and lead acetate Pb(CH3COO)2. Lead acetate readily converted to loose lead carbonate, releasing acetic acid, thus establishing a cyclic corrosion process. In contrast, lead formate formed a compact crystalline structure that offered some protection to the substrate at low-to-medium humidity levels (≤75% relative humidity). However, its corrosiveness remained significantly higher compared to the acid-free environments. Consequently, the use of display and storage materials that emit formic acid or acetic acid must be strictly avoided in the preservation and exhibition of lead-based artifacts.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回